Art napisal: Poleg tega je tu še tegoba v načinu oz. kriterijih vrednotenja, kar ni nikjer (predvidevam, da namenoma) natančno opredeljeno; Denimo, da ima nek mehanizem 250 sestavnih delov. Kako jih bomo razporedili po pladnju v razmerju 60/40 in rekli; tile morajo biti izdelani v Švici, ostali pa so lahko pač kjerkoli ?
Po številu gotovo ne, (bi bilo preveč banalno, da bi odbrali 150 vijačkov in drugega »drobiža« in rekli, to je sedaj 60 % in lahko pritisnemo Swiss made..)
Po teži tudi gotovo ne, zaradi podobno neprimernega kriterija.
Po volumnu, po kompliciranem izgledu, po dejanski težavnostni stopnji izdelave?
Kaj je torej tisto kar prinaša verodostojen merljiv odstotek, ki zadovolji postavljeni zakonodaji?
To je edino relevantno vprašanje, na katerega pa nikjer nisem našel odgovora.

Mislim da tu ne bi smelo biti tezav. Vsak sestavni del je hkrati tudi potencialen rezerveni del, kar pomeni, da mora imet svojo katalosko ceno. Iz tega sledi, da % izracun ne bi smel bit tezak.

Malo nazaj smo o kriterijih 'Swiss made' Že razpravljali.

Sedaj so jih še zaostrili: www.fhs.swiss/eng/swissmade.html

Definition of the Swiss watch
A watch is to be regarded as a Swiss watch if:
a. its technical development has taken place in Switzerland;
- in the case of exclusively mechanical watches, at least the mechanical construction and prototyping of the watch as a whole,
- in the case of watches that are not exclusively mechanical, at least the mechanical construction and prototyping of the watch as a whole, together with the conception of the printed circuit or circuits, the display and the software;
a.1 its movement is Swiss;
b. its movement has been cased up in Switzerland;
c. final inspection by the manufacturer took place in Switzerland and
d. at least 60% of the manufacturing costs is generated in Switzerland

To be regarded as a Swiss movement, the movement must:
a. have undergone technical development in Switzerland:
- for exclusively mechanical movements, at least mechanical construction and prototyping of the movement as a whole,
- for movements that are not exclusively mechanical, at least mechanical construction and prototyping of the movement as a whole, together with the conception of the printed circuit or circuits, conception of the display and conception of the software;
a.1 have been assembled in Switzerland;
b. have been inspected by the manufacturer in Switzerland and
b.1 at least 60% of the manufacturing costs must be generated in Switzerland and
c. at least 50% of the value of all the constituent parts, but excluding the cost of assembly, must be of Swiss manufacture.

Odstotki kot pogoj za 'swiss made' so precej majhni. IMHO...

Zanimivo potezo je v tem primeru naredil Moser, ki se je odločil, da povsem opusti napis 'swiss made'. In po svoje jim dam povsem prav. Do neke mere je namreč uspelo razvrednotiti (vmes je imel še DIESEL svoje poiskuse z limited edition urami, ki so prav tako nosile napis 'swiss made', česar pa ne gre enačiti z čim, ki pride izpod rok kakšne izmed in-house manufaktur, katerih številčnica spet nosi isti napis).

še malce bolj obsežno, če koga zanima
monochrome-watches.com/h-moser-cie-removes-swiss-made-from-its-watches-and-teases-us-with-the-upcoming-most-swiss-watch-ever-created/

Swiss made je huda 'blagovna znamka' . In Švicarji so dost pametni, da jo bodo znali zascitit. Z dvigom kriterijev npr

Sem zadnjič prebral isto zadevo o H. Moser & Cie . Je pa zabaven posnetek, ki so ga objavili na youtube na to temo

Germanski humor lol ... raje naj delajo ure, sir, čokolado ipd, to obvladajo